Justice for KevanJustice for KevanStory, evidence and legal context

Intrinsic Worth CSC

A legal argument that the CSC must be judged against human dignity, not only control

This 2011 article by solicitor Shahida Begum examines Close Supervision Centres through dignity, mental-health harm and Article 3. For Kevan, that matters because his fight for innocence has unfolded inside prison systems that can isolate, restrict and make it harder for a person to be heard.

DignityThe article starts from the principle that every person has intrinsic worth, even inside the most restrictive prison setting.
OversightIt questions whether IMBs, HMCIP and the courts can prevent abuse where CSC conditions are severe.
Article 3It argues that isolation, sensory deprivation and mental suffering cannot be dismissed as ordinary prison management.

The manual describes containment in small, highly supervised units

The purpose of the CSCs can briefly be stated from a sentence taken from the CSC Referral manual:

"The role of the CSC is to remove the most seriously disruptive prisoners from main location prison and contain them instead in small, highly-supervised units"

The concept of segregation in CSCs can be broken down in to three main components; sensory deprivation, social isolation and confinement. Use of CSCs could be argued to respect a prisoners' intrinsic worth if it is evidenced in policy document that one component, or a combination of components do not affect a prisoners' mental health. Where such confirmation is lacking it question its legitimacy.

As a starting point in the management of these prisoners, a group of proper legitimate values on which to base the CSCs must be established. Everybody can see that implementing alternative and appropriate measures to deal with problematic situations and prisoners, and fostering a prison environment respectful of dignity, is perhaps, the prison services most promising initiative and the only legitimate management tool.

The article asks whether prison watchdogs had enough power to protect dignity inside CSCs

The three main bodies charged with the dignity of prisoners have limitations leaving a wide scope for abuse of prisoners subject to rule 46.

IMBThe article says Independent Monitoring Boards could criticise the prison system, but lacked statutory power to change staff decisions or higher policy.
HMCIPIt records inspection criticism of extreme sensory deprivation and concern that CSC eligibility criteria appeared to have broadened.
Why it mattersIf oversight can name harm but cannot stop it, people inside the CSC remain dependent on outside pressure and legal challenge.

The legal question is whether austerity becomes inhuman or degrading treatment

The conditions of the CSC unit have been judged as austere, but it is yet to be tested in the courts whether they amount to a breach of art.3 of the ECHR.

Art.3 provides an absolute prohibition on torture, and inhuman or degrading treatment, irrespective of the prisoner's conduct. The protection afforded by art.3 is absolute and an argument based on balancing security measures against prisoners' art.3 rights is a misconceived one. Security risk posed by the prisoner will be taken into account when determining whether any measures constitutes a breach. The principle of respect of the prisoners' dignity is the standard for determining whether the treatment rose to the level of severity as required by art.3

Treatment causing mental suffering is sufficient to fall within the provision, provided a sufficient degree of intensity is reached. Provided it is sufficiently real and immediate, a mere threat of conduct prohibited by this provision may itself be in conflict with it.

Part of the prison record Kevan has had to fight through

Kevan is fighting a wrongful conviction while the prison system has repeatedly placed him inside high-control conditions. Dignity, mental health and the ability to challenge injustice cannot be treated as luxuries.

Dignity is practicalA person cannot prepare, communicate and keep fighting properly if isolation is allowed to erode their health and voice.
Oversight has to mean protectionCriticism after the event is not enough when the harm happens inside closed prison units.
The case and prison record connectKevan's innocence fight is inseparable from the conditions he has had to survive while pursuing it.

The article ends by calling for a serious review of CSC admission criteria

Art.3 may be breached by the state due to the cumulative effect of a number of different measures or conditions within CSCs. As lawyers we can assist in practical ways, but the real test is for those labouring under illusions about CSC initiatives to recognise CSCs are more than just austere. After 12 years of attesting to balance incommensurable values, the time is ripe for a review of the new criteria for admission to the CSC, to ascertain whether they are (as claimed) consistent with the purpose and effective running system and whether reforms are warranted to safeguard the dignity of prisoners, is an attack on their dignity and is also an attack on the dignity of each and every one of us.

Shahida Begum- Solicitor-Cooper Rollason Solicitors, Shropshire

Read this beside the wider CSC record

Messages of support

Show your support for Kevan or comment on this article.

No messages are public yet.Share support for Kevan below.